Liberty Aldermen Deny Request to Place Public Safety Radio Tower Near Fire Station

November 6, 2024
By: Dwayne Page

A new state funded public safety communications tower planned for the Liberty area will have to be erected somewhere else other than the proposed location at the Liberty Fire Station.

During a meeting Monday night, members of the Liberty town council voted against allowing the tower to be placed on the grounds of the Liberty Fire Station, which is jointly owned by both the towns of Liberty and Dowelltown but under a long-term lease with the county for use by the fire department and EMS. The tower was intended to improve currently unreliable emergency radio communication at no cost to either the county or city governments.

Although county officials say this particular site is not in the actual city limits of either Liberty or Dowelltown and not subject to city ordinances or restrictions, they sought the blessing of both city governments to move forward with this project. The Dowelltown Mayor and Aldermen reportedly had already met and given their approval.

Liberty, Aldermen J.D Bratten, Ryan Dodd, Kevin Mullinax, Howard Reynolds Jr., and Kendra Stanford all voted no on the proposed tower location and with the request having been rejected, another suitable location will be sought out, even if it means perhaps the state working out a deal with a landowner on privately owned property in the Liberty area.

The Liberty mayor and members of the town council held a public meeting Saturday morning, October 19 to give residents a chance to learn more and speak out about the proposed tower.

Among those at the October 19 meeting to explain why the tower was needed were DeKalb 911 Director Brad Mullinax: Jeff Gray, Director of the Tennessee Advanced Communication Network, and County Mayor Matt Adcock. County Fire Chief Donny Green and EMS Director Trent Phipps were also at the meeting in support.

Gray explained that this proposal was not for a privately owned cell tower. Its strictly for public safety and was being proposed and to be funded and maintained by the Tennessee Advanced Communications (TACN) network intended to provide first responders the ability to better communicate locally and have additional coverage to talk on the radio with surrounding state communication towers during major events and disasters. In recent months the county began funding upgrades from its old analogue system to new state of the art portable, mobile and fixed radio transmission technology and it joined the Tennessee Advanced Communications Network (TACN) to eventually make the transition complete.

According to Gray, the state looks to place its towers on property already owned by either state or local governments and it tries to avoid making deals with private landowners or cell phone companies mainly due to unforeseen future costs.

“The first place we look at is state owned property and then county owned properties with a long-term lease and then private property but that comes with a challenge in potential ownership changes or cell tower compatibility. With an initial $2 million dollar investment per tower site, Gray explained that exploring other alternatives for tower location privately could become cost prohibitive over time.

“If Liberty says no we will have to look for another spot,” said Gray. “The challenge is we will have to find another spot with an equal height that allows us to look over the topography,” said Gray.

“We have never had good radio coverage in Liberty and Dowelltown so we started looking at ways to fix that with the TACN system,” said 911 Director Brad Mullinax. “ It is very important that we get a good public safety radio system. I am just asking for your consideration to approve this. It is much needed,” said Mullinax.

A few residents at the October 19 meeting, while acknowledging that better emergency radio communication is needed, said there should be more than one option to locate this tower.

“I think everybody here is in agreement that we need it. Its just where it goes. There is only one option on the table and that doesn’t make sense to me,” said one Liberty resident.

“I understand there is a need, but I would like to see what the other options are,” said another resident who lives near the proposed tower site. “Yes, its an eyesore. A 300-foot tower is huge. I already have one in my back yard and now I could have one in my front yard. I’ll be sandwiched in between the two towers. As an investment, a lot of people now don’t like seeing a (tower close by) and you can’t give property away with two towers setting like this, but I know lives are more important,” he said.

“We are for the tower but if you built a house on this property and a tower goes up next to it that’s not what you expected futuristically down the road, you have questions and we have lived in Liberty our whole life,” added another concerned resident.

One woman, who lives near the Liberty Fire Station, said she had no problem with a new tower being erected close to her home.

“I live right in front of the fire department and have lived here for almost 43 years. I don’t understand what the big deal is about the tower. It is needed. The communication down here has been sorry for years. This tower is going to go in my front door. I’m for the change. If that tower is going to change things for your emergency people, they need it,” she said.

WJLE Radio